How many homes are for sale in Bay Street?

Active MLS inventory in Bay Street updates throughout the day. Browse this page for live counts, prices, and photos, or set up a saved search to be notified the moment a new home is listed.

What is the average price of a home in Bay Street?

Median list prices in Bay Street are computed from current MLS listings and shown on this page. Actual sold prices and HOA fees vary by floor plan and view — confirm the latest with the listing agent.

Does Bay Street have an HOA?

HOA status varies by community and even by phase within the same community. Each MLS listing on this page shows the HOA fee, frequency, and what it covers. Always review the HOA documents and budget before making an offer.

How can I get notified when a new home is listed in Bay Street?

Create a free saved search filtered to Bay Street. You'll get an email the moment a new home, price change, or status change matches your criteria.

Home ValueLive MLS— updated daily

Coast 2 CoastHome Realty

Florida › Osprey › Bay Street Village

Bay Street Village Homes for Sale

🔒 Gated community🏊 Resort-style amenities🎓 Top-rated schools

Homes for sale

$298K

Average price

$239

Avg $ / sqft

Avg days on market

Listings Amenities Schools What's Nearby Open Houses Solds Neighborhoods

Welcome to Bay Street Village

Bay Street Village in Osprey

Bay Street Village is a resort-style community in Osprey, Florida, built by D.R. Horton between 2014–2018. Buyers choose from condominiums, townhomes, all with access to a resort-style amenity campus featuring clubhouse, fitness center, pool, gated — no guard gate, buyer approval required. Families are drawn to Laurel Nokomis Elementary, Laurel Nokomis Middle, Venice Senior High and quick access to I-75, Waterside and Main Street dining, and the Gulf beaches about 40 minutes west. There are currently 6 homes for sale, with an average list price around $298K.

Commute to Work

See the drive time from Bay Street Village to your office, gym, or anywhere that matters.

Know before you tour

Bay Street Village Quick Facts

Builder

D.R. Horton

Year Built

2014–2018

Home Types

Condo · Town

Pets

Yesw/ restrictions

Rentals

Yesw/ restrictions

55+

CDD

Variesby home

Inside Bay Street Village

For sale now

Homes For Sale in Bay Street Village

Create a Search for Bay Street VillageGet new listings the moment they hit the market

Map unavailable

ACTIVE

GATED

$260,000

DOM: 124•$229/sqft· MLS #MFRA4689541

Condo For Sale

4271 EXPEDITION WAY #103

OSPREY, 34229

View all Bay Street homes →

2 bd2 ba1,135 sqft

HOA

—

CDD

—

Taxes

$3,507.17/yr

Laurel Nokomis ElementaryLaurel Nokomis MiddleVenice Senior High

ACTIVE

GATED

$294,900

DOM: 107•$237/sqft· MLS #MFRA4692249

Townhome For Sale

184 EXPLORER DR

OSPREY, 34229

View all Bay Street homes →

2 bd2 ba1,244 sqft

HOA

$475/mo

CDD

—

Taxes

$3,473.89/yr

Pine View SchoolPine View SchoolPine View School

ACTIVE

GATED

$299,000

DOM: 133•$263/sqft· MLS #MFRA4687965

Condo For Sale

4226 FRONTIER LN #103

OSPREY, 34229

View all Bay Street homes →

2 bd2 ba1,135 sqft

HOA

$475/mo

CDD

—

Taxes

$3,541.59/yr

Laurel Nokomis ElementaryLaurel Nokomis MiddleVenice Senior High

ACTIVE

$299,990

DOM: 80•$264/sqft· MLS #MFRA4694926

Townhome For Sale

4296 EXPEDITION WAY #104

OSPREY, 34229

View all Bay Street homes →

2 bd2 ba1,135 sqft

HOA

—

CDD

—

Taxes

$3,507.17/yr

Laurel Nokomis ElementarySarasota MiddleVenice Senior High

ACTIVE

GATED

$317,000

DOM: 47•$222/sqft· MLS #MFRA4698337

Condo For Sale

4213 EXPEDITION WAY #107

OSPREY, 34229

View all Bay Street homes →

3 bd2 ba1,430 sqft

HOA

$475/mo

CDD

—

Taxes

$3,428/yr

Laurel Nokomis ElementaryLaurel Nokomis MiddleVenice Senior High

ACTIVE

GATED

$320,000

DOM: 88•$221/sqft· MLS #MFRA4694435

Condo For Sale

89 NAVIGATION CIR

OSPREY, 34229

View all Bay Street homes →

2 bd2 ba1,449 sqft

HOA

—

CDD

—

Taxes

$3,931.17/yr

Laurel Nokomis ElementaryLaurel Nokomis MiddleVenice Senior High

Lifestyle

Bay Street Village Amenities

Life at Bay Street Village

6 of 16 amenities

Clubhouse

Resort Pool

Fitness Center

Spa & Sauna

Lifestyle Director

Walking Trails

Dog Park

Playground

Golf

Tennis

Pickleball

Basketball

Bar / Restaurant

Boating / Water Access

Gated Entry

55+ Community

HOA & lifestyle

What's Included in Bay Street Village

Your HOA fees include

Approx. $475/mo

Pool
Maintenance Grounds
Water
Escrow Reserves Fund
Maintenance Structure
Sewer
Trash

Community features

◆Clubhouse

◆Fitness Center

◆Pool

◆Gated — No Guard Gate

◆Buyer Approval Required

◆Community Mailbox

◆Irrigation-Reclaimed Water

◆Sidewalks

◆Deed Restrictions

Sarasota County · FL DOE Grades

Bay Street Village Assigned Schools

School Report Card

Source: FL Dept. of Education

ABCDF

Elementary

Middle

High

Google Maps · Drive times

What's Nearby Bay Street Village

Map unavailable

Loading nearby places…

Stay in the loop

Open Houses in Bay Street Village

🗓

Never miss an open house in Bay Street Village

We'll send you every open house scheduled in Bay Street Village — plus new listings and price changes — the moment they hit the MLS.

✓ This weekend's open houses
✓ New listings & price drops
✓ No spam — unsubscribe anytime

Open houses

Sign up for Open Houses in Bay Street Village

Get this weekend's open houses + any new ones the moment they're scheduled.

Market report · last 12 months

Bay Street Village Market Report

Loading market data…

🔒

Market

See Sold Prices in Bay Street Village

Unlock the actual closed prices, addresses, and photos for every recent sale in this community.

Thinking of selling?

See What Your Home's Worth

Get an instant, no-obligation home value report for your Bay Street Village home — powered by live MLS sales and market trends.

Or open the full home value report →

Good to know

Bay Street Village FAQs

Is Bay Street Village a gated community?+

Gating varies by phase; each listing notes its access. We can confirm for any home you're considering.

What are the HOA & CDD fees?+

HOA dues run around $475/mo and typically cover Pool, Maintenance Grounds, Water. A CDD assessment may also apply and appears on the annual tax bill.

Are pets and rentals allowed?+

Both are generally allowed with restrictions per the Bay Street Village community documents — we'll pull the exact rules for any home you're considering.

Who builds in Bay Street Village?+

Bay Street Village features homes by D.R. Horton.

Never miss a new listing

Create a Search for Bay Street Village

Get new Bay Street Village listings, price drops, and open houses the moment they hit the MLS — free, and you can unsubscribe anytime.

Explore the area

Other Osprey Neighborhoods

Seairefrom $266K Star Farms At Lakewood Ranchfrom $367K Bella Lagofrom $350K Legacy Preservefrom $329K Rye Crossingfrom $364K Saddlestone At Star Farms Lakewood Ranchfrom $307K Coddingtonfrom $312K Toscana Islesfrom $380K

Community guide

About Bay Street Village

Life in Bay Street Village

Bay Street Village is built around an active, resort-style lifestyle. Residents enjoy clubhouse, fitness center, pool, gated — no guard gate, buyer approval required. It's the kind of place where you can start the morning at the fitness center, spend the afternoon by the pool, and meet neighbors at a community event that evening.

HOA, CDD & What's Included

HOA dues in Bay Street Village run about $475 per month and typically cover Pool, Maintenance Grounds, Water, Escrow Reserves Fund. Like many Lakewood Ranch communities, a CDD assessment may also apply and shows up on the annual tax bill. We'll walk you through the exact fees for any home you're considering so there are no surprises.

Location & What's Nearby

Set in Osprey, Bay Street Village keeps everyday essentials minutes away — Publix and shopping at Lakewood Ranch, dining at Waterside Place and Main Street, and I-75 for an easy commute toward Sarasota, Bradenton and Tampa. Sarasota-Bradenton International Airport is roughly a half-hour away, and the white-sand Gulf beaches of Anna Maria Island and Siesta Key make for an easy day trip.

Schools & the Local Market

Bay Street Village is served by Laurel Nokomis Elementary, Laurel Nokomis Middle, Venice Senior High. With an average list price around $298K and homes selling close to asking, the community remains one of Osprey's most in-demand addresses. Whether you're buying your first home or right-sizing, our team can share live sold data and help you act quickly when the right home hits the market.

Your Local Bay Street Village Advisor

Thinking about Bay Street Village?

Get honest answers about available homes, builder incentives, HOA and CDD fees, schools, amenities, and whether Bay Street Village is the right fit for you.

25 years of Florida real estate experience

Current MLS listings & builder incentives

Independent, no-pressure buyer guidance

Ask Frank a Question

Call (941) 962-3177 Text Frank Video Chat

Your information stays private. No pressure and no obligation.

Frank Harris

Broker/Owner · Coast 2 Coast Home Realty